Stock image: dirt road through dry savanna, Okonjima Nature Reserve, Namibia. Photo: Josep M. Gracia, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 (cropped).
What a ranger's first hour at a wildlife crime scene has to protect
Wildlife crime tends to happen a long way from a police station. The UNODC forensics brochure puts it plainly: these offences commonly occur in remote regions with little likelihood that dedicated crime scene investigators can attend, so everyone in wildlife law enforcement needs a working awareness of crime scene principles. On a reserve or in a park, the first person at a scene is often a ranger or a member of the anti-poaching team. The investigator comes later, and what the investigator finds depends on what that first person did and did not do.
This piece looks at what the first hour has to protect, and at the questions a reserve manager or station commander can ask of their own team.
A case is built on what is still there
By the time a case reaches court, the evidence is only as useful as the account of where it has been. UNODC notes that legal challenges to the chain of custody are common during court proceedings, and that evidence has to be managed correctly from the moment it is identified at the scene until it enters court proceedings. A defence lawyer does not need to say the evidence is false. It is enough to ask who handled it, when, and whether anyone can show that nothing changed.
That puts a lot of weight on people who are usually trained to do something else. A ranger arriving at a scene is trained to be alert, to stay safe and to deal with any threat. Those instincts are right for the first few minutes. After that, the task changes.
Mostly restraint, and a notebook
Much of what the published guidance on wildlife crime scenes asks of a first responder is restraint. Cooper, Cooper and Budgen, writing in Endangered Species Research, describe marking out the scene, keeping a record of who enters it, and allowing no unnecessary admittance. They also describe contamination, meaning the introduction of extraneous material, as an easy mistake to make when visiting a scene. They also say that notebooks for written information are essential.
None of that needs special equipment. It needs someone who decides, quickly, that the scene is now evidence, tells the rest of the team to stay out of it, and writes down times, positions and names. A notebook entry made in the first few minutes may be the only record of what the scene looked like before anyone walked through it.
Keep the chain short
Cooper and colleagues also make a point that is easy to overlook. The chain of custody should be as short as possible, and ideally it should not include anyone who is unwilling to appear in court or unlikely to be a reliable witness. Every additional person who touches an item is another link that may be questioned.
For a private reserve, this raises a practical matter. Who may pick up an item, who may store it, and who hands it to the police? One set of international protocols for live wildlife crime scenes says private persons, such as members of NGOs, should never be assigned to transport or store evidence, because of the concern it creates for chain of custody. What a reserve team may do will depend on national law and on how the local police work, so it is better agreed in advance with the police than worked out at the scene.
The guidance exists, and it says what it is not
UNODC and the African Wildlife Forensics Network have published a Wildlife Crime Scene Guide for First Responders. It is written for people working under non-optimal conditions, with limited equipment and limited personnel. It also says of itself that it is not a training manual, and that it assumes the reader already has the knowledge and training to act as a first responder.
That is a fair description of where the gap is. A reserve team can ask for a copy of the guide. Our view, from the training side, is that a guide in a pocket is not the same as having done it before: in your own terrain, tired, with the radio going and a colleague wanting to look closer. We think that is where practice matters more than reading.
Questions to ask of your own team
Who does the first person on the scene call, and is that number written down somewhere other than one person's phone?
What does the team carry to mark off a scene and record it? A notebook and a camera with the date and time set are a start.
Who is allowed to touch or move an item, and who writes down that they did?
When the police arrive, how is the scene handed over, and is the handover written down?
When did the team last practise the first hour, rather than read about it?
If several of those are hard to answer, that is useful to know before the next incident rather than after it.
Where we fit
Liberty Walk Group trains rangers, police and security teams from Windhoek. Our Reserve Readiness membership for private reserves in Namibia includes quarterly refresher days that cover arrest and evidence procedures, matched to the reserve's own terrain and threat. If you would like to talk about how your team handles the first hour, write to info@libertywalkgroup.com.
Sources
UNODC, Wildlife Forensic Science (brochure), "Crime scene and evidence management"
UNODC / African Wildlife Forensics Network, Wildlife Crime Scene Guide for First Responders (2019)
Image: stock photo, "Dirt road through the dry savanna of Okonjima Nature Reserve, Namibia, 2007" by Josep M. Gracia via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0; cropped.
Talk to us about your team's first hour: info@libertywalkgroup.com · Reserve Readiness