Skills fade when they are not practised

Stock image: human footprints in red Kalahari sand at Anib Lodge, Namibia. Photo: Mozzihh / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0), cropped. Not LWG training or a real incident.

What the research shows about skill fade after a course, and five questions a reserve or station can ask of its own team.

A training course is a concentrated period of practice. People leave it sharper than they arrived. The harder question is what that team can still do three, six or twelve months later, when the instructor has gone and ordinary work has taken over.

None of this is an argument against courses. Research on what happens to trained skills during periods of non-use finds a consistent pattern: the longer a skill sits unused, the more of it is lost. This piece looks at that evidence, and at the questions a reserve manager or station commander can ask before the next high-risk season.

What the research actually shows

In 1998, Arthur, Bennett, Stanush and McNelly published a meta-analysis of skill decay, drawing on 189 independent data points from 53 studies. Their published abstract reports little skill loss immediately after training (an effect size, d, of −0.01) and substantial loss after more than 365 days of non-use (d of −1.4). We have not obtained the full article, only the published abstract and a later review of those figures.

A more recent analysis looked specifically at procedural skills, the kind that combine knowledge with doing, and at longer gaps than many earlier studies. In a 2023 doctoral dissertation at the Georgia Institute of Technology, Corey Tatel brought together 1,352 effect sizes from 457 sources. Accuracy-based performance declined by 0.08 standard deviation units per month of infrequent use, and speed-based or mixed performance by 0.06 per month. The initial gains from training were typically lost between one year and two and a half years after they were acquired, if the skills were not used consistently.

Those figures do not come from anti-poaching units, and we should not pretend they do. They come from a wide mix of trained procedural work. They are still a useful warning. The skills a ranger team may need most under pressure, including casualty care, an arrest and a crime-scene handover, are often the ones used least in an ordinary week. First aid research makes the same point in a narrower field. The Global First Aid Centre, the International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies' reference centre for first aid, states that knowledge and skill decline dramatically in the months after an initial first aid course, and that refreshers are better delivered three to six months later. Waiting longer, it says, leads to less effective learning.

What a course date does not tell you

On a reserve, it is easy to treat the last course date as the current standard. The people are the same. The certificates are in a file. On a quiet afternoon, that can look like readiness.

The International Ranger Federation's State of the Ranger report, published in 2024 from surveys collected in 2023, gives a more mixed picture of how training is actually maintained. The report includes 1,286 ranger responses from 81 countries and 287 employer responses from 65 countries. Sixty-two per cent of ranger respondents said they had received an introductory course, while 83 per cent of employers said they offered one. When asked if refresher training was offered, just over half of employers said rangers had received additional training, and a higher share of employers than rangers said refreshers were offered. Less than 60 per cent of both groups said they had provided or received emergency response or first aid refresher training. About 80 per cent of employers and rangers believed rangers were adequately trained for their duties, and rangers still reported that more training was needed in all aspects of their work.

The useful point is not that anyone is misleading anyone. It is that "we trained them" and "they have practised it recently" are different statements, and they are easy to confuse.

Staff rotation makes the gap wider. A team that was together on a course in March is not always the same team in November. New people inherit the standard only if someone has a plan for them.

Questions to ask of your own team

  • Which skills on your unit are used every week, and which are used only when something goes wrong?

  • After the last course, what was the plan for practising the second group, and who owned that plan?

  • When did the team last rehearse a casualty drill, an arrest or a crime-scene handover, in your own terrain, rather than talk through it?

  • If two people left tomorrow, which procedures would reside only in their heads?

  • When a new ranger or officer joins, how do they reach the same standard as the people who went on the last course?

If several of those are hard to answer, that is useful to know before the high-risk months rather than during them.

Where we fit

Liberty Walk Group trains rangers, police and security teams from Windhoek. Our Reserve Readiness membership for private reserves in Namibia is built around this problem: quarterly training visits that include patrol drills, tracking, scenario work, arrest and evidence procedures, and casualty care, matched to the reserve's own terrain and threat, plus a year-long plan that takes account of seasonal risk and staff rotation. If you would like to talk about how your team holds its standard between courses, write to info@libertywalkgroup.com.

Sources

Image: stock photo, Human footprints on red sand of Kalahari desert, Anib-Lodge, Namibia, 2016 by Mozzihh via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0; cropped. Not Liberty Walk Group training or a real incident.

Next
Next

Before the investigator arrives